METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES TO UNDERSTANDING THE CATEGORY OF "SYSTEM OF SOURCES OF CONSTITUTIONAL LAW"
Abstract
This article says that, since the sources of constitutional law have many common features, but at the same time differ from each other, such a situation makes it difficult to solve the tasks facing a particular state body, leads to instability of the legal system of the state as a whole. In particular, a sufficient number of various kinds of conflicts arise, numerous violations of the rule of law are allowed, which ultimately affects the overall effectiveness of the state, the level of ensuring the implementation and guarantees of citizens' rights and freedoms. And to overcome such negative aspects, there is a methodology of a systematic approach to understanding the category "system of sources of constitutional law", which allows you to determine the system and structure of sources, the place of a particular source in the system, the reflection in it of the scope of powers of the relevant subject of law, subordination of sources of law by legal force, the relationship between different types of sources, an adequate measure of legal regulation. The author makes an attempt to comparatively analyze the system of sources of constitutional law of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Uzbekistan.
Downloads
References
Smolensky M. B., Markheim M. V. Constitutional law of the Russian Federation: Textbook. Rostov n/A, 2003. pp. 15-19.
Gabrichidze B. N., Chernyavsky A. G. Constitutional law of Russia. M., 2004. p. 121.
Kutafin O. E. Sources of constitutional law of the Russian Federation. M., 2002. pp. 22-23.
Analysis of various interpretations of the system / Z. M. Orujev. Dialectics as a system. M., 197.5.
Anokhin L. K. Philosophical aspects of the theory of a functional system // Vopr. filosofii. 1971. No. 3. P. 15.
Lebedev V. A., Antsiferova O. V. Ensuring the unity of the legislative system of the Russian Federation. M., 2005. P. 7.
Legal cybernetics / Ed. V. N. Kudryavtsev, M., 1970; Management. Sociology. Right / Edited by I. V. Pavlov, V. P. Kazimirchuk, M., 1971; Kozlov V. A. Questions of the theory of the effectiveness of a legal norm: Abstract. ... cand. Jurid. L., 1972; Law and Sociology / Ed. Yu. A. Tikhomirov, V. P. Kazimirchuk. M., 1973; Alekseev S. S. The structure of Soviet law. M., 1974. The exception is the work of: Tiunova L. B. Systemic connections of legal reality. St. Petersburg, 1991; Atamanchuk G. V. Theory of public administration. M., 1997.
Nazarov B. L. Socialist law in the system of social relations. M., 1976. p. 176.
Philosophical dictionary / Edited by I. T. Frolov, M., 1986.
P. 427.10. General theory of law and the state. M., 1996. pp. 168.
Kravets A. S. Probability and systems. Voronezh, 1970. p. 36.
Afanasyev V. G. System and society. M., 1980. p. 71.
Kravets A. S. Decree. soc. p. 38.
Nersesyants V. S. Philosophy of Law. M., 2000. P. 256.
Lebedev V. A., Antsiferova O. V. Decree. Op. S. 9.
Aristotle Metaphysics // Op.: In 4 volumes, 1975. Vol. 1. pp. 148-149, 174-175.
Bertalanfi L. N. History and status of the general theory of systems // The World of philosophy: Book for reading: In 2 ch. 1. Initial philosophical problems, concepts and principles. M., 1991. p. 294.
Avtonomov A. S. Methodological aspects of the study of the system of categories of constitutional law // Theoretical problems of Russian constitutionalism. M., 2000. p. 10.
Belsky K. S. On the system of administrative law // State and law. 1998. No. 3. p. 5.
Komarov S. A. General theory of State and law: Textbook M., 1997. P. 271.
Galperin L. B., Lebedev P. I. Cybernetics and management of social processes // Vopr. theory of owls. rights. 1966. p. 23.
Sadovsky V. N. Systems and structures as specific subjects of modern scientific knowledge // Problems of research of systems and structures. M., 1965.
Problems of the general theory of law and the state: Studies for universities / Edited by V. S. Nersesyants. M., 1999. p. 328; Blauberg I. V., Sadovsky V. N., Yudin E. G. A systematic approach to modern science // Problems of methodology of system research. M., 1970.
Uemov A. I. Svyaz // Philosophical Encyclopedia: In 4 volumes. M., 1967. Vol. 4. p. 570.
Kondakov P. I. Logical dictionary-reference. M., 1975. p. 524.
On the types of connections of organic systems, see: Blauberg I. V., Yudin E. G. The formation and essence of a systematic approach. M., 1973. pp. 186-192.
Alekseev S. S. General theory of law: Course in 2 volumes. M., 1981. Vol. 1. p. 292.
Lukyanova E. A. Law as a source of Soviet state law. M., 1988. P. 9.
Kechekyan S. F. Theory of state and law. M., 1949. p. 21.
General theory of State and law: Academic course: In 2 vols. 2. Theory of law / Edited by prof. M. N. Marchenko. M., p. 141.
Alekseev S. S. Law: ABC – theory – philosophy: the experience of a comprehensive study. M., 1999. pp. 77.
Lukyanova E. A. Decree. op. p. 10.
Rumyantsev O. G., Dodonov V. N. Legal encyclopedic dictionary. M., 1997.
Constitutional Law: Studies / Ed. by A. E. Kozlov, M., 1996. Pp. 14-15.
Baglay M. V. Constitutional law of the Russian Federation: Studies for law schools and faculties. 2nd ed., ed. and additional M., 1999. pp. 18-29.
Mishin A. A. Constitutional (state) law of foreign countries: Textbook. M., 1996. pp. 12.
Kutafin O. E. Decree. soc. S. 22.
Strekozov V. G., Kazanchev Yu. D. Constitutional the law of Russia. M., 1997. P. 9.
Antsiferova O. V. Ensuring the unity of the legislative system of the Russian Federation: Dis. ... cand. Jurid. sciences'. Chelyabinsk, 2003. p. 20.
Theory of State and law: Studies. / Edited by V. K. Babaev. M., 1999; Polenina S. V. Theoretical problems of Soviet legislation. M., 1979. pp. 4-5.
Tiunova L. B. Decree. soc. p. 55; Talyanin V. V. The legislative system of modern Russia// Actual problems of theory and history of state and law: Materials of the interuniversity. scientific theory. Conf., St. Petersburg, December 19. 2002 / Under the general editorship of V. P. Salnikov, R. A. Romanov. St. Petersburg., 2003. pp. 196-199; Tikhomirov Yu. A. Legal conflict. M., 1994. P. 33; Livshits R. Z. Theory of law: Textbook M., 1994. p. 112.
Kutafin O. E. Decree. op. s. 16.
Alekseev S. S. Philosophy of law: History and modernity. Problems. Trends. Prospects. M., 1999; Bogdanova N. A. The system of science of constitutional law. M., 2001.
Alekseev S. S. General theory of law. Vol. 2. p. 192.
Zivs S. L. Source of law. M., 1981. p. 35.
Lukyanova E. A. Decree. soc. p. 16.
Kravets I. A. Formation of Russian constitutionalism (problems of theory and practice). Novosibirsk, 2002. p. 188.
